Vote of No Confidence in Superintendent Tracy Dorland

Posted on: May 29, 2025
Posted By: Christine Wiggins
Posted in: Community News

The below letter was presented to the members of the Jeffco Public Schools Board of Education during public comment on May 29, 2025. 

Dear Board Directors Parker, Reed, Kenworthy, Varda, and Applegate,

The Jefferson County Education Association Representative Council and Board of Directors, the elected voice of thousands of educators in Jeffco Public Schools, have taken the extraordinary but necessary step of issuing a Vote of No Confidence in Superintendent Tracy Dorland.

This decision was not taken lightly, but is a reflection of the overall direction of the district under Superintendent Dorland’s leadership which has created a disconnect between the central administration and the educators, families, and communities we serve. While we had hoped to build a relationship grounded in shared purpose and trust, what we have seen and what has been shared with us has been exclusion, top-down mandates, and a general disregard for collaborative processes.

Superintendent Dorland’s continued leadership has exacerbated tensions, widened the gap between decision-makers and stakeholders, and damaged the district’s credibility with employees and the broader community.

Our vote of no confidence was made for the following reasons:

1. Disregard for Shared Leadership and our Community 

It is critical in any school district that all stakeholders have a meaningful voice in decision making.  We had hoped to see leadership that empowered educators, families, and community members to help shape the future of our schools.  Instead we have seen Superintendent Dorland’s leadership defined by unilateral decisions that often ignore the voices of those most affected.

  • Presenting health care changes to the Board of Education before the Benefits Advisory Committee made a recommendation
  • Failure to listen to the voices of the Jefferson Jr/ Sr Community or communicate with stakeholders in an ongoing and authentic way. This includes failing to research and recommend multiple options to the Board or community for the future of Jefferson Jr/ Sr that reflect the needs of the students and families that currently attend the school.
  • Announcing sweeping changes to Alternative Education Campuses (AEC) without a real seat at the table for stakeholders. Initial refusal to pause, explain, or roll back all announced changes and agree to provide both a voice and a vote to AEC educators.
  • Lack of engagement with the Middle School Healthy & Equitable Start & End Times Work Group and a failure to follow recommendations from that group.
  • Fostering institutional instability by creating a culture of excessive turnover among central administration positions, making it difficult to have any continuity of service or support for educators, parents, or students.

2. Lack of Transparency and Accountability

While we acknowledge that some decisions affecting schools, staffing, and student services must be made quickly and some are the purview of the Superintendent’s Office, too often decisions in Jefferson County Public Schools have been made behind closed doors without explanation. We have seen time and again a failure to engage in fair and transparent communication with our communities.

  • Rather than relying on the existing experience and skills of district educators and staff, Superintendent Dorland’s administration has often chosen to spend our limited public dollars in concerning ways, making use of high-cost, third-party consultants. These external voices are too often given more power than the professionals working in our schools every day, while educators are told to do more with less.
    • Including: school closures, multiple different AEC studies, and evaluation rubrics and “look-fors.”
  • The district has demonstrated a troubling lack of commitment to the bargaining process delaying meaningful proposals, disregarding collaborative workgroup recommendations, and failing to engage in good faith on issues that directly impact staff and students. This includes claiming at the table, and communicating to school leaders, that if impasse were declared, all articles which were agreed to at the bargaining table could be reopened as a part of the impasse proceedings, which is absolutely not a show of good faith bargaining nor how the impasse process works.
  • Removal of books from school libraries without adherence to district protocol or Board Policy.
  • Failing to deliver on bargaining commitments made in the 2023-2024 school year to bring caseload and workload recommendations to the bargaining table. The District has shown no commitment to make meaningful change for the professionals who work with our students who need additional support.
  • When concerns have been raised, rather than engaging in meaningful problem solving, we have consistently seen district leadership blame building level administrators, claim miscommunications, or other variations of “blaming-shaming-explaining.”
  • The disempowerment of multiple collaborative work groups, including in the Leaves Working Group, following Benefits Advisory Committee and District Accountability Committee recommendations.
  • Lack of investment and support in receiving schools who have had to “buy-up” DTLs, SELs, and more while struggling with class sizes at or over recommended guidelines and limited space.
  • Failure to engage all stakeholders in changes to the Growing and Changing Curriculum and making these changes behind closed doors without communicating them to the community or the School Board.

3. Failure to Address Urgent Conditions in Schools

We have continued to share our concerns about unsafe learning environments, insufficient student and educator mental health support, and unsustainable workloads, especially in special education and alternative education settings. Instead of partnering with educators to find solutions, Superintendent Dorland has dismissed or delayed action while morale, retention, and student outcomes suffer.

  • Lack of communication to the Jeffco community regarding how schools will respond to information requests or appearances at school by ICE, followed by a rejection of the Board resolution and directive on safe schools, including how to manage ICE.
  • Failure to intervene and/or address multiple concerns about student safety and building level support for interventions for student behaviors, including:
    • Ralston Valley High School, where a student was reportedly vomiting blood and an administrator refused to allow the clinic aide and school nurse to call 911;
    • Mitchell Elementary where parents and staff raised urgent concerns about staff and students being routinely harmed. When these issues were raised by the educator in a meeting with Superintendent Dorland and Deputy Superintendent Dr. Kym, the teacher was yelled at, a similar event occurred when Mitchell parents attended a board meeting to express concerns;
    • Minimal communication to the community regarding charges and investigation into the former Chief of Schools, including cancelling the planned “State of the District” address.
  • Divesting of resources in equity work, including shrinking the number of EDI specialists from three to one, ending trainings that support diversity and inclusion like the Diversity Expo.
  • Making changes to the Toolkit for Supporting Transgender and Gender Expansive Students without input from students and families in these communities, and removing educator access to the toolkit from the employee website.
  • Changing policies around pronoun use in email signatures without including educators or Board members impacted by these policies.

Superintendent Dorland’s approach has repeatedly undermined trust, destabilized our schools, and diverted valuable time and resources away from classrooms. Her leadership style is fundamentally misaligned with the values our community expects and our students deserve.

Therefore, the Jefferson County Education Association Representative Council has taken a unanimous Vote of No Confidence in Superintendent Dorland.

We call on you, as the Board of Education, to take swift and decisive action to restore collaborative governance and to reestablish confidence in the leadership of Jeffco Public Schools. Our educators are ready to work with you to rebuild a district grounded in partnership, equity, and transparency, but we cannot do so under the current Superintendent’s direction. We need you to ensure that there is accountability, transparency, and true shared decision-making from your employee, Superintendent Dorland.

In Solidarity,

The Jefferson County Education Association Operational Board

The Jefferson County Education Association Representative Council

Related Posts